START WITH THESE SUGGESTIONS:

Animal crackers

Assorted berries

Brownies

Candy coated chocolates

Chocolate nonpareils and dark chocolate candy bars

Cookies

Gummy bears

Macarons

Mini doughnuts

Sugar wafers

ADD:

Caramel corn

Caramel fruit dip

Chocolate-covered pretzels

Mini fruit kabobs

Fudge sauce

Gumdrops

Graham crackers

Hazelnut spread

Marshmallow fluff

Peanut butter